Contradiction with 2 Samuel 5:8
This verse attributes the capture of Jerusalem to David himself, whereas 1 Chronicles 11:6 credits Joab.
2 Samuel 5:8: And David said on that day, Whosoever getteth up to the gutter, and smiteth the Jebusites, and the lame and the blind, [that are] hated of David's soul, [he shall be chief and captain]. Wherefore they said, The blind and the lame shall not come into the house. [Wherefore...: or, Because they had said, even the blind and the lame, He shall not]
Paradox #1
One contradiction related to this verse is the identity of who led the attack on the Jebusites in Jerusalem. In 2 Samuel 5:8, it is suggested that David himself led the attack and gave a command regarding the Jebusites, which seems inconsistent with 1 Chronicles 11:6, where Joab is credited with leading the attack and becoming chief. This difference in accounts causes confusion about the roles of David and Joab in this event.
Paradox #2
The potential contradiction in this verse could be about the promotion of violence and rewarding it. By offering leadership positions to those who engage in acts of war or aggression, it might seem inconsistent with other biblical teachings that emphasize peace, humility, and love for others. This can appear as a conflict between the values of encouraging aggression for leadership and promoting peace and compassion.
Paradox #3
1 Chronicles 11:6 states that Joab became chief because he was the first to attack the Jebusites. However, another passage, 2 Samuel 5:8, suggests that David promised the chief position to whoever struck the Jebusites first, making it seem like Joab’s appointment wasn't directly tied to an explicit event mentioned there. This can create a perception of inconsistency regarding how Joab was appointed as chief.