Acts 9:7 Contradictions and Paradoxes

According to Luke, the men traveling with Saul were very surprised because they heard a voice talking but couldn't see anyone around them. They didn't know what was happening, so they stood there without saying anything.

Contradiction with Acts 22:9

This verse contradicts Acts 9:7 because it states that the men with Saul did not hear the voice, whereas Acts 9:7 mentions they did hear a voice.

Acts 22:9: And they that were with me saw indeed the light, and were afraid; but they heard not the voice of him that spake to me.

Paradox #1

Acts 9:7 is often compared to Acts 22:9, where there seems to be a contradiction. In Acts 9:7, it states that the men with Saul heard a sound but didn't see anyone, whereas in Acts 22:9, it says they saw the light but didn't understand the voice. This appears inconsistent because one account emphasizes hearing, while the other focuses on seeing without hearing clearly. Understanding the verses in context or considering translation nuances can help reconcile the differences.

Paradox #2

The contradiction or inconsistency related to "Acts 9:7" involves another verse, "Acts 22:9." In "Acts 9:7," it is mentioned that the men with Saul heard a voice but saw no one. However, in "Acts 22:9," it states that Saul's companions saw the light but did not understand the voice. The potential conflict is whether or not the men heard or understood the voice during Saul's experience.

Paradox #3

Acts 9:7 is sometimes seen as inconsistent because it says the men with Saul heard a voice but didn't see anyone. However, Acts 22:9 suggests the men didn't hear the voice but saw the light. This difference in the accounts about what the men experienced can be seen as a contradiction.

Paradox #4

One possible inconsistency is between "Acts 9:7" and "Acts 22:9." In "Acts 9:7," it is described that the men traveling with Saul heard a voice but did not see anyone. However, in "Acts 22:9," it says that they did not hear the voice of the one speaking. This creates a contradiction regarding whether the men heard the voice or not.

Paradox #5

Acts 9:7 is sometimes seen as inconsistent with Acts 22:9, where different accounts are given about what Paul's companions heard during his vision. In Acts 9:7, it's suggested they heard a voice, while Acts 22:9 implies they didn't understand the voice or hear it clearly. The conflict arises in whether they actually comprehended what was spoken or heard the voice at all.

Paradox #6

The contradiction related to Acts 9:7 is its apparent inconsistency with Acts 22:9. In Acts 9:7, it is stated that the men with Saul heard a sound but saw no one, while in Acts 22:9, Saul says that his companions saw the light but did not understand the voice speaking to him. This creates a contradiction about whether Saul's companions heard or didn’t hear the voice.