Contradiction with Jeremiah 7:22
This verse states that God did not speak to or command the Israelites concerning burnt offerings and sacrifices when He brought them out of Egypt, which contrasts Amos 5:25's implication that they were expected during the 40 years in the wilderness.
Jeremiah 7:22: For I spake not unto your fathers, nor commanded them in the day that I brought them out of the land of Egypt, concerning burnt offerings or sacrifices: [concerning: Heb. concerning the matter of]
Contradiction with Exodus 24:5
This verse details the Israelites offering burnt offerings and peace offerings of oxen to the Lord, suggesting that sacrifices were made, contradicting the implication in Amos 5:25 that sacrifices were not offered.
Exodus 24:5: And he sent young men of the children of Israel, which offered burnt offerings, and sacrificed peace offerings of oxen unto the LORD.
Contradiction with Numbers 28:3-6
These verses describe the continual burnt offering commanded by God, which seems to contradict Amos 5:25's suggestion that sacrifices were not the focus during the wilderness period.
Numbers 28:3-6: And thou shalt say unto them, This [is] the offering made by fire which ye shall offer unto the LORD; two lambs of the first year without spot day by day, [for] a continual burnt offering. [day by day: Heb. in a day]
Paradox #1
The potential contradiction in Amos 5:25 arises when comparing it with other parts of the Old Testament that emphasize the importance of sacrifices and offerings as part of worship practices. While Amos 5:25 questions the significance of these sacrifices by focusing on justice and righteousness instead, other texts suggest that sacrifices were a key component of following God’s commands. This could be seen as inconsistent in the emphasis placed on ritual practices versus moral behavior.
Paradox #2
Amos 5:25 questions whether the Israelites offered sacrifices during their 40 years in the wilderness. This creates a conflict because other parts of the Bible, like the books of Exodus and Leviticus, describe detailed rituals and sacrifices during that period. This inconsistency raises questions about the historical accuracy of these practices among the Israelites in the wilderness.
Paradox #3
Amos 5:25 raises a question about whether the Israelites offered sacrifices to God during their forty years in the desert. The contradiction could stem from the contrast between religious rituals and genuine faithfulness or obedience to God. It might lead to questioning if performing rituals without sincere devotion holds any true value.