Contradiction with John 5:6-9
These verses describe Jesus healing the man without the need for the stirred water, emphasizing direct intervention over the angel-stirred pool.
John 5:6-9: When Jesus saw him lie, and knew that he had been now a long time [in that case], he saith unto him, Wilt thou be made whole?
Paradox #1
John 5:4 is not found in many modern translations of the Bible because it is missing from the earliest and most reliable manuscripts. Its absence raises questions about its authenticity and whether it was part of the original text. This can lead to confusion or inconsistency when comparing different Bible versions, as some include the verse while others omit it entirely.
Paradox #2
The potential contradiction or inconsistency with John 5:4 arises from its absence in many of the earliest and most reliable Greek manuscripts of the New Testament. Some scholars believe it was added later to provide context, leading to questions about its authenticity. Therefore, there might be debates about its legitimacy and its alignment with the rest of biblical scripture.
Paradox #3
John 5:4 is considered a later addition to the Bible and doesn't appear in many early manuscripts. This discrepancy suggests that it might not have been part of the original text, leading to debates over its authenticity and inclusion.
Paradox #4
John 5:4 is often seen as lacking strong historical or textual support, as it is missing from many early manuscripts. This fact could be considered an inconsistency or conflict regarding its authenticity or originality in the text.