Contradiction with Luke 22:33
Just like Mark 14:31, this verse does not directly contradict but rather parallels Peter's insistence on his loyalty.
Luke 22:33: And he said unto him, Lord, I am ready to go with thee, both into prison, and to death.
Paradox #1
Theological discussions sometimes point out a potential inconsistency between Mark 14:31 and other Gospel accounts regarding Peter's denial. In Mark, Peter emphatically states he will not deny Jesus, but in the accounts of other Gospels, the wording and circumstances around Peter's claim might differ slightly, leading to discussions about Gospel harmony. However, these differences are usually explained as variations in testimony rather than outright contradictions.
Paradox #2
One potential contradiction related to "Mark 14:31" is the difference in how Peter's denials are described across the four Gospels. In Mark, Peter insists he will not deny Jesus, but in all four Gospels (Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John), Peter eventually does deny Jesus. The number of times, the context, and the specifics of these denials can differ slightly from one Gospel to another, which might lead to questions about consistency in the accounts.
Paradox #3
The possible contradiction in Mark 14:31 could be related to the idea of loyalty and promises. The verse involves a promise of unwavering loyalty, but soon after, this promise is broken. The contradiction arises in how humans often declare strong commitments or beliefs, yet fail to uphold them when challenged or under pressure. This highlights the inconsistency between intentions and actions.