Contradiction with Proverbs 31:6
This verse suggests giving strong drink to those who are perishing, contrasting with the refusal of wine to Jesus in Mark 15:23.
Proverbs 31:6: Give strong drink unto him that is ready to perish, and wine unto those that be of heavy hearts. [of...: Heb. bitter of soul]
Contradiction with Matthew 27:34
In this verse, Jesus tastes the vinegar mixed with gall but does not drink, which contrasts with His refusal in Mark 15:23.
Matthew 27:34: They gave him vinegar to drink mingled with gall: and when he had tasted [thereof], he would not drink.
Paradox #1
Mark 15:23 mentions Jesus being offered wine mixed with myrrh, which He did not take. A potential contradiction comes when comparing this account to Matthew 27:34, where Jesus is offered wine mixed with gall. These accounts differ slightly in the substance offered and accepted, leading to discussions about the consistency of Gospel narratives. However, many theologians see these as complementary, focusing on the symbolic meaning rather than literal differences.
Paradox #2
The potential contradiction in Mark 15:23 could involve the question of compassion. If the verse is seen as offering Jesus something to ease his suffering, refusing it might seem at odds with the idea of accepting help or compassion when in need. Alternatively, if it suggests indifference to suffering, it might conflict with the values of empathy and kindness.