Contradiction with John 19:34
This verse states that one of the soldiers pierced Jesus' side with a spear, which some interpret as happening after His death, whereas in Matthew 27:49, this act is implied to occur before His death.
John 19:34: But one of the soldiers with a spear pierced his side, and forthwith came there out blood and water.
Contradiction with Mark 15:36-37
In this passage, Jesus is said to cry out and then immediately give up the ghost after being offered vinegar, while Matthew 27:49 implies an additional act (piercing) before His death.
Mark 15:36-37: And one ran and filled a spunge full of vinegar, and put [it] on a reed, and gave him to drink, saying, Let alone; let us see whether Elias will come to take him down.
Paradox #1
Matthew 27:49 can be seen as having a contradiction with John's account of the crucifixion in John 19:34. Matthew suggests something occurs prior to Jesus' death, while John presents this event as happening after his death. This difference in timing can be seen as a contradiction between the two Gospel accounts regarding the sequence of events during the crucifixion.
Paradox #2
The contradiction comes from different Gospel accounts about when the events surrounding Jesus' death happened. In Matthew, it seems like something happened before Jesus died, but in other Gospels, it is noted to happen after. This causes some confusion about the sequence of events.
Paradox #3
Some ancient manuscripts of the Gospel of Matthew include a line absent in most modern translations, suggesting that Jesus was given vinegar to drink before he cried out and died. This parallels a verse in the Gospel of John, sparking debate and confusion about the sequence of events. This discrepancy in the narrative can lead to questions about consistency between the Gospel accounts.
Paradox #4
The contradiction or conflict in this verse might arise from differing accounts of events. Different versions of this story in the Gospels present variations, leading to questions about the accuracy and consistency of the narrative. This could create confusion about what actually happened, creating a moral issue around truthfulness or reliability.
Paradox #5
The contradiction or inconsistency in Matthew 27:49 arises when comparing it to the account in John 19:34. In Matthew, it seems as though Jesus is alive when a certain event is described, while in John, a similar event is stated to occur after Jesus has died. This creates a disagreement about the timing of that event between the two accounts.